I assume you mean captain was a spy? I think there may be something in this. Would definitely be a smart move if Heef was a baddy. Unfortunately if it's Heef & captain, our best bet would be to send teacups and Morgie again, with 2 unknowns. But if it's Morgs and/or tkp that's the spy, then were fucked. I think it's gonna boil down to taking a punt on it, 50/50 chance really. If it's Morgie or tkp, Go Captain, Heef, blunder and one other? If it's Heef & captain Go Morgie, tkp, blunder and one other? I don't think we've had 2 in one night since there's only been one fail vote each night yeah?
Blunder could well replace Heef as the spy there too. Would just have been a fluke rather than spy strategy.
The irritating thing about your plan, is there are still 2 or 3 spies left out of the remaining 5 players which makes the odds of guessing correctly pretty low indeed. Yet it seems to be the only thing we can do
Put Furball in. Only one who wasn't happy with the previous mission. If it were up to me I'd go Furball, Captain, Howe and Weeman.
Furball I've made a point for Captain because of the point of him not being teacups/morgie who're under the most suspicion Howe because I trust myself ofc Weeman because I think he's talking sense
Yeah it's gonna be tough no matter what. Were gonna have to pick the right spies and the pick the right randoms. Furball could be a good shout.
And yet by believing Captain is innocent you're subscribing to the 'one of Tkp and morgie' is a spy theory which leaves 3 in the final 5. Hence at least one of weeman, yourself and furball MUST be a spy. You're smarter than that Howe
Both missions have failed and IIRC both of them have been on both missions. This is why I objected to Teacups going last time, because that's an easy frame job if he's a townie.
Yeah exactly. So now our choice is whether to take a punt on Captain or not. If we believe Captain is innocent, then chances are myself and Heef are. If not then one of myself and Heef are spies. So we either stick morgie and tkp back in with 2 randoms or Captain, myself and Heef in with 1 random.
Yeah this is going to be a huge risk. GF should go IMO and probably Howe for suggesting it but that's not fool proof either. Plus we need to decide on two more.
I just remember Howe being the one who suggested it. I didn't actually pay much attention to his proposed group, oops GF should be one of the people who goes next though. I think Weeman raised a good point in that it's unlikely there's more than one spy in the first group. However there only being one in second group is unlikely based on his reasoning of "they can't communicate so they won't run the risk of passing it as a spy." I think it's already been mentioned here but Heef could have been a spy himself and his inclusion in the group signals that he probably will fail the mission himself so he doesn't need one of his fellow spies to fail it again. So he can easily include another spy in there. So that gives us one spy out of: Captain Morgie Teacups At least one spy out of (durrr) TKP Morgie Heef Blunder Well, now we've reached a dead end. Scenario: Captain is the spy Means morgie and Teacups are extremely unlikely to also be a spy. Because if either of those two are spies, they would fail it themselves and wouldn't rely on any other to fail it. This scenario seems the most unlikely considering that morgie and Teacups were in the next group and there was one fail again. So Captain should go again. So we have GF Captain Obviously me proposing that I go again is not something that people would want to gamble on and I completely understand. My hunch is Heef and morgie are spies. Failing that, just morgie and he failed both missions. Cunt.
I hate probability so much. So not my strong point. Having read the arguments I'm going to offer: Captain Heef Blunder GF
One no vote from Weeman. Five yes votes from Heef, Blunder, Howe, Furball and morgie. Plus Ritchie makes six. Since Heef and Captain were spies, that mission would have failed and the spies won. Howe and Tart the other two spies.
