Battlestar Galactica Mafia

Discussion in 'Forum Games and Activities' started by Athlai, Feb 23, 2013.

  1. Skippos SM Morgan

    ftr, before this game I'd never watched BSG. Now I've watched 73/74 eps I'm pretty sure and haven't watched the last episode. I'm not sure I ever will - I've loved it so much I never want it to truly end. I watched Starbuck's last scene on youtube a few days ago and (I was in an emotional state at the time I must confess) cried for about 4 hours seriously. I was that entrenched and engrossed and attached to the show. I've also taught myself all the music from it and watched all the comicon-esque panels of the cast and all that.

    Such an amazing show - realistic as far as sci-fi goes, such an awesome focus on characters and development and an amazingly well written, convoluted yet simple plot.

    Without a doubt the best show I've ever watched. I can't remember legitimately crying during movies/tv shows much if ever but this one is so amazing I did.

    Worth it guys. Really worth it - even if the first few eps struggle to engross you, as happened to me - continue a little longer and it will.

    Gonna have to watch blood & chrome/razor/caprica now and all will probably be shit.
     
  2. Number 11 CJ Downes

    Just wondering. Did you start with the mini-series or first ep proper?
     
  3. Eddie EI Morris

    Bad times :(
     
  4. Skippos SM Morgan

    Me? First ep. Yet to watch the miniseries.

    A massive regret too, I should have.
     
  5. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Oh wow. Might watch it myself then.

    Mafia has made me watch/re-watch/read more into a lot of things already. GW CricSim.
     
  6. Number 11 CJ Downes

    Ok. Will try the miniseries first then I guess.
     
  7. Howe JHF Howe

    I watched the mini-series first and it isn't really as good and the themes are a bit different. But I'm glad I watched it first as it lays out a lot of context for the characters in the series proper, especially for Roslin and Baltar.
     
  8. Skippos SM Morgan

    Haha yeah. If someone asked me to give a top 10 list of shows I wouldn't be able to as there are genuinely only about 6-7 tv shows I genuinely like and ATM it's 1. BSG Daylight Nightlight 2. whatever comes next. I'm sure in a month when I'm finished it'll be down a bit but still will be number one with ease.

    Took me awhile to get into it though, like watched it and new girl at the same time and I ended up watching 30 new girl eps before finishing 12 BSG eps but now have watched 70 BSG eps before finishing 40 new girl eps it just clicked for me.

    First season is good but didn't have the addictive qualities of the early second season and beyond.

    No real 'MOTW' or planet of the week themes either which is gun. Just a story the whole way through.

    Couldn't endorse it more and I rarely endorse tv shows.
     
  9. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah I can't imagine it being that good but it probably provides a bit of necessary context.
     
  10. Howe JHF Howe

    It does, and if it didn't have that I probably wouldn't watch it owing to having no structure whatsoever. It's just that there's no real travelling or exploratory aspect to the weekly stories, which are better put as "problem of the week".
     
  11. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Haha Skippos used my X-Files reference that I stole off %A Bannerman like 8 years ago. That 5 minute conversation we had lives on, pasag.
     
  12. Skippos SM Morgan

    Season 3 and late season 2 do have the 'problems of the week' aspect I guess but these problems all focus on a different character (I actually mentally compared it to Skins in that aspect - each episode had relevance to the continuous theme but focused on a different character) and explore and develop them foremost while deal with the problem second most. Given I'm the biggest sucker for character development I kind of negate the POTW aspect given IMO the main focus is the characters, not the problem.
     
  13. Skippos SM Morgan

    huh?
     
  14. Skippos SM Morgan

    Did I grab that phrase off you? Wow. Didn't even know.
     
  15. Skippos SM Morgan

    one of the most amazing things to do with BSG especially post season one is the effect and relevance of the music too. never seen a show have such well composed and relevant music. it's just amazing.

    I'm genuinely in love.
     
  16. Howe JHF Howe

    That's true but it's foolish to suggest the show isn't episodic. Every episode, with the occasional two-parter, there is some problem threatening the fleet and by the end of the episode it's resolved. There are tons of longer arcs and it's character-focused but that's clearly the structure of the show.
     
    Last edited: Mar 18, 2013
  17. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah I'll confess my original comment was rash but what I really mean is despite the episodic nature you're alluding to, the problems take a secondary focus while the main arc/character developments take the primary focus & that's something I haven't really seen before, at least to the extent they do it.
     
  18. Mousey AJ Son

    How does it rate compared to Firefly and Stargate? They're my measuring sticks and I only saw part of S1 years ago.
     
  19. Skippos SM Morgan

    Like with the exception of Tyrol (mainly because the actor chosen to play him wasn't a good fit) I can't really think of a poorly written or delivered character - even someone like Apollo who was the biggest dweeb became a gun due to his development.

    I guess Dualla was pretty shit but I think she was intended as a tool to develop other primary characters. Tory Foster was the biggest disappointment of the show actually.

    But the fact that I can only find 3 faults in character development is gun as I usually find +50.

    Such a gun show. Gonna rant and rave all day until I watch the last episode and cry in the dark for a month.
     
  20. Howe JHF Howe

    Firefly is hard to rate because there's so little of it. I think if you were to give me a choice between watching a Firefly episode or a BSG episode I'd enjoy watching Firefly more, but I've got more out of BSG as a show because it's actually a proper story.
     

Share This Page