The Mighty Heefs/Gwilty as Charged

Discussion in 'CPL Aussie Rules' started by MightyPies, Apr 7, 2013.

Page 5 of 9

  1. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Why did MP pick Nathan Brown with pick 4? Surely a little early on, wasn't it?

    Anyway, I thought I'd keep Selwood rather than Mackie as I get the feeling Mackie is starting to decline whilst Selwood could (in theory at least) still improve. But, for a first round versus a 5th round you might well be right in value terms.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 16, 2014
    #81

  2. Skippos SM Morgan

    Mackie had the best season of his career last season (made the all australian best 22) and is bettering it so far this season though.


    MP picked brown because he supports collingwood. Most biased kid out there.
     
    Skippos, Apr 16, 2014
    #82

  3. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    But surely there were better picks from Collingwood left at that stage anyway?
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 16, 2014
    #83

  4. Skippos SM Morgan

    As a full back brown's quite good. Defensively he doesn't make errors and keeps his man honest. Purely on defense he's probably a round 4-6 pick.

    He's just incredibly injury prone and offers nothing in offense.
     
    Skippos, Apr 16, 2014
    #84

  5. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Mitch Golby has been injured and will miss 3 weeks (Heef)
    Nathan Brown has been injured and will miss 2 weeks (Heef)
    Daniel Giansiracusa has been injured and will miss 2 weeks (Heef)
    Nick Haynes has been injured and will miss 1 week (Heef)
    Ben Cunnington has been injured and will miss 1 week (Heef)

    Returning:
    Stefan Martin
    Daniel Rich
    Brent Macaffer

    FB: Matthew Jaensch - Beau Maister - Tom Logan
    HB: Chris Yarran - Mitch Brown - Andrew Mackie
    M: Sharrod Wellingham - Scott Selwood - Michael Rischitelli
    HF: Stefan Martin - David Hale - Chris Masten
    FF: Josh Hill - Jack Riewoldt - Jamie Elliott
    R: Dean Cox - Daniel Rich - Stephen Coniglio
    Int: Marley Williams - Chris Knights - Brent Macaffer
    Sub: Jamie MacMillan

    Does the return of Martin give me the option of playing him down the middle and moving Hale and would there be any benefit in doing that anyway?

    The changes I've otherwise made are Rischitelli in for the injured Cunnington (booo), Jaensch to BP to replace Morris. Yarran at HBF. I have a desire to drop Josh Hill but don't think I've got many options there.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 19, 2014
    #85

  6. Skippos SM Morgan

    Quite simply I just wouldn't play Martin.

    He's just not very good
     
    Skippos, Apr 19, 2014
    #86

  7. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Stick Yarran at HFF and Williams at HBF, maybe?
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 19, 2014
    #87

  8. Skippos SM Morgan

    I'd keep Morris in defence. Still one of the best defenders around despite not getting many stats
     
    Skippos, Apr 19, 2014
    #88

  9. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Really? Doesn't look like he's performed at all in this.

    So you reckon this?

    FB: Dale Morris - Beau Maister - Tom Logan
    HB: Matthew Jaensch - Mitch Brown - Andrew Mackie
    M: Sharrod Wellingham - Scott Selwood - Michael Rischitelli
    HF: Chris Yarran - David Hale - Chris Masten
    FF: Josh Hill - Jack Riewoldt - Jamie Elliott
    R: Dean Cox - Daniel Rich - Stephen Coniglio
    Int: Marley Williams - Chris Knights - Brent Macaffer
    Sub: Jamie MacMillan
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 19, 2014
    #89

  10. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah, that looks significantly better.

    Also really important to have that third tall in there in case the opposition plays 3 talls. Morris acts as that third tall.
     
    Skippos, Apr 19, 2014
    #90

  11. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Ah yeah. I forgot about the whole 3rd tall thing.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 19, 2014
    #91

  12. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah if you don't want Morris trade him to me :p

    He's really one of your most valuable, can play on smalls or talls and shut them down equally as well.
     
    Skippos, Apr 19, 2014
    #92

  13. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    15. MightyPies/Heef - Scott Selwood 513 (24)
    18. MightyPies/Heef - Jack Riewoldt 451 (25)
    34. MightyPies/Heef - Dean Cox 526 (32)
    63. MightyPies/Heef - Nathan Brown (Collingwood) 261 (25)
    66. MightyPies/Heef - Andrew Mackie 486 (29)
    95. MightyPies/Heef - Chris Masten 491 (24)
    98. MightyPies/Heef - Stefan Martin 243 (27)
    127. MightyPies/Heef - Daniel Rich 448 (23)
    130. MightyPies/Heef - Sharrod Wellingham 398 (25)
    159. MightyPies/Heef - Stephen Coniglio 456 (20)
    162. MightyPies/Heef - Chris Yarran 386 (25)
    191. MightyPies/Heef - David Hale 426 (29)
    194. MightyPies/Heef - Jamie Elliott 410 (21)
    223. MightyPies/Heef -Nick Suban 365 (23)
    226. MightyPies/Heef - Ben Cunnington 514 (22)
    255. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Brown (WCE) 287 (25)
    258. MightyPies/Heef – Josh Hill 355 (25)
    287. MightyPies/Heef – Dale Morris 290 (31)
    290. MightyPies/Heef – Michael Rischitelli 398 (28)
    319. MightyPies/Heef – Chris Knights 305 (27)
    322. MightyPies/Heef – Brent Macaffer 306 (26)
    351. MightyPies/Heef – Daniel Giansiracusa 317 (32)
    354. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Golby 386 (22)
    383. MightyPies/Heef – Beau Maister 246 (28)
    415. MightyPies/Heef – Jamie MacMillan 375 (22)
    418. MightyPies/Heef – Matthew Jaensch 414 (24)
    447. MightyPies/Heef – Adam Kennedy 318 (21)
    450. MP/Heef - Jack Newnes 375 (21)
    482. MP/Heef - Jason Tutt 230 (22)
    511. MightyPies/Heef – Marley Williams 404 (20)
    514. MP/Heef - Kyle Martin 332 (23)
    543. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Clisby 369 (24)
    386. MightyPies/Heef – Nick Lower Tom Logan 345 (28)
    479. MightyPies/Heef – Lukas Markovic Nick Haynes 356 (21)

    Any issues there? I see Williams got a suspended sentence so should make his way back into the Collingwood line-up at some point.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 30, 2014
    #93

  14. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah and he's a good player. Worth retaining.

    Newnes should definitely be retained, looking really good this season. I'd probably switch Golby with him as Golby's looking well out of touch right now.

    If you can find a way to get Macaffer in it'd be ideal but I'm not sure who you'd drop for him. Masten perhaps? There'd likely be a better midfielder available in the 6th round than him.
     
    Skippos, Apr 30, 2014
    #94

  15. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    I'd tossed up whether to keep Newnes or not. I haven't seen Golby play this season, so have no idea. Given Newnes is a lower pick, I can see the value but I don't think I can find space for Macaffer.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 30, 2014
    #95

  16. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    15. MightyPies/Heef - Scott Selwood 513 (24)
    18. MightyPies/Heef - Jack Riewoldt 451 (25)
    34. MightyPies/Heef - Dean Cox 526 (32)
    63. MightyPies/Heef - Nathan Brown (Collingwood) 261 (25)
    66. MightyPies/Heef - Andrew Mackie 486 (29)
    95. MightyPies/Heef - Chris Masten 491 (24)
    98. MightyPies/Heef - Stefan Martin 243 (27)
    127. MightyPies/Heef - Daniel Rich 448 (23)
    130. MightyPies/Heef - Sharrod Wellingham 398 (25)
    159. MightyPies/Heef - Stephen Coniglio 456 (20)
    162. MightyPies/Heef - Chris Yarran 386 (25)
    191. MightyPies/Heef - David Hale 426 (29)
    194. MightyPies/Heef - Jamie Elliott 410 (21)
    223. MightyPies/Heef -Nick Suban 365 (23)
    226. MightyPies/Heef - Ben Cunnington 514 (22)
    255. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Brown (WCE) 287 (25)
    258. MightyPies/Heef – Josh Hill 355 (25)
    287. MightyPies/Heef – Dale Morris 290 (31)
    290. MightyPies/Heef – Michael Rischitelli 398 (28)
    319. MightyPies/Heef – Chris Knights 305 (27)
    322. MightyPies/Heef – Brent Macaffer 306 (26)
    351. MightyPies/Heef – Daniel Giansiracusa 317 (32)
    354. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Golby 386 (22)
    383. MightyPies/Heef – Beau Maister 246 (28)
    415. MightyPies/Heef – Jamie MacMillan 375 (22)
    418. MightyPies/Heef – Matthew Jaensch 414 (24)
    447. MightyPies/Heef – Adam Kennedy 318 (21)
    450. MP/Heef - Jack Newnes 375 (21)
    482. MP/Heef - Jason Tutt 230 (22)
    511. MightyPies/Heef – Marley Williams 404 (20)
    514. MP/Heef - Kyle Martin 332 (23)
    543. MightyPies/Heef – Mitch Clisby 369 (24)
    386. MightyPies/Heef – Nick Lower Tom Logan 345 (28)
    479. MightyPies/Heef – Lukas Markovic Nick Haynes 356 (21)

    Jaensch looks to be good value now, as does Cunnington.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Apr 30, 2014
    #96

  17. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    15. MightyPies/Heef - Rory Sloane
    18. MightyPies/Heef - Jack Riewoldt 451 (25)
    34. MightyPies/Heef - Dean Cox 526 (32)
    63. MightyPies/Heef - Pearce Hanley
    66. MightyPies/Heef - Andrew Mackie 486 (29)
    95. MightyPies/Heef - Chris Masten 491 (24)
    98. MightyPies/Heef - - Ted Richards
    127. MightyPies/Heef - Daniel Rich 448 (23)
    130. MightyPies/Heef - James Gwilt
    159. MightyPies/Heef - Stephen Coniglio 456 (20)
    162. MightyPies/Heef - Cameron Pedersen
    191. MightyPies/Heef - David Hale 426 (29)
    194. MightyPies/Heef - Jamie Elliott 410 (21)
    223. MightyPies/Heef -
    226. MightyPies/Heef - Ben Cunnington 514 (22)
    255. MightyPies/Heef –
    258. MightyPies/Heef –
    287. MightyPies/Heef –
    290. MightyPies/Heef –
    319. MightyPies/Heef –
    322. MightyPies/Heef –
    351. MightyPies/Heef –
    354. MightyPies/Heef –
    383. MightyPies/Heef –
    415. MightyPies/Heef – Jamie MacMillan 375 (22)
    418. MightyPies/Heef – Matthew Jaensch 414 (24)
    447. MightyPies/Heef –
    450. MP/Heef - Jack Newnes 375 (21)
    482. MP/Heef -
    511. MightyPies/Heef – Marley Williams 404 (20)
    514. MP/Heef -
    543. MightyPies/Heef –
    386. MightyPies/Heef –
    479. MightyPies/Heef – Nick Haynes 356 (21)
     
    Last edited: Jun 20, 2014
    HeathDavisSpeed, Jun 9, 2014
    #97

  18. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    FB: Marley Williams - Ted Richards - x
    HB: Pearce Hanley - Nick Haynes - Andrew Mackie
    M: Rory Sloane - x - Ben Cunnington
    HF: x - David Hale - Chris Masten
    FF: x - Jack Riewoldt - Matthew Jaensch
    R: Dean Cox - Stephen Coniglio - Daniel Rich

    Int: Jack Newnes

    Looks like I'm in need of talls. Especially tall backs, aye?
     
    Last edited: Jun 13, 2014
    HeathDavisSpeed, Jun 9, 2014
    #98

  19. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    Haynes can play tall but you'd be well served getting at least another KPD.
     
    MatthewJay, Jun 10, 2014
    #99

  20. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Ted Richards hopefully fills a void in the team.
     
    HeathDavisSpeed, Jun 13, 2014
    #100
Page 5 of 9

Share This Page