http://www.cricsim.com/site/stats.php?season=12&comp=3&team=3 They've both played every game and been awful. Clough slightly less awful but Perry has more credit in the bank from previous seasons. Might axe both and play Steele or something. I only just noticed that the Saders have actually played the same XI in every game so far this season, except this one, and only because Wilson was injured. Pretty neat.
Holy shit, didn't realise how bad Old Mate had been this season. And if I'm theoretically in the team, we don't really need his bowling either. As you say though, if one goes, Old Mate probably stays due to his past.