Baxter did pass the check to determine Skippos was the mafia, but mariner failed it and Baxter failed to convince him otherwise.
Nominations are separate from voting. Voting only occurs after no more nominations are made. Since he would win either way he voted randomly.
Intelligence:7 Intuition:2 Involvement:3 Innocence:1 Inference:2 Aggressiveness:High Specialty:Town Signing up.
Intelligence:5 Intuition:1 Involvement:3 Innocence:3 Inference:3 Aggressiveness: Medium Specialty: Mafia
Intelligence:5 Intuition:7 Involvement:1 Innocence:1 Inference:1 Aggressiveness: Medium Specialty: Town