There's 8 left, 3 of us are maf. AVA can lynch the lead suspect so we need morgie to vote with us, not just abstain. Then tonight we kill a police and you can't get a lynch tomorrow. If morgie votes with the town at any stage, the maf lose anyway, and may as well kill morgie for it. If survival is one of his win conditions then he should vote with the maf. If he's town aligned then obvs he votes with you. If neither, then he can just decide who wins.
I call bullshit on the 3, but even so, AVA lunches you that leaves 4 town, 2 mafia and Morgie. Even with Morgie on your side, you lose on votes. If we vote Morgie off we lose on numbers as you'd knock off one of the townies over night. so yeah, Morgie kinda has to vote with us.
There are 3. I can get them to confess if morgie doesn't believe me. In fact they'll have to, because I need them to lynch GIMH with me. If if we get morgie on board it's 4-4 for today, no lynch, and we can take the win with the next two night kills. You can't get the numbers to lynch morgie so he only lives if he votes with us.
We can't afford to lynch you either way Morgs, and you'd be betting on there being as many mafia as they tell you. With us you're guaranteed to win as we need you vote to win. You'd also finish the game a day quicker, so I'd go with our option.
What I'm saying is you'd be a taking a risk, however slight it is, with them, but you're guaranteed to win with us. if we lynch Uppercut tonight that leaves 3 town after they knock one of us off, likely 2 mafia and you. If anyone votes you you can vote with the mafia and force a NL and win with them. We are forced to keep you alive for votes and cannot lynch you at any stage, so please vote with us - it's in both of our best interests.
As soon as you get numbers to 3-3 and Morgie you're going to kill him anyway because why win it together when you can kill him off, force a NL and win it the next night? We don't have a way of getting rid of someone without votes, so Morgie is a 100% integral part of our plan m8
Why would we kill morgie at 3-3 NL? We could choose anyone and still win. I'd pick hedger. Also, we know you don't have a doc. Everyone's declared another role.
So I guess it's fairly clear that Uppercut is maf - not convinced that one, or both, of Mousey and GIMH are at all in the clear though.
Why would you choose to win with Morgie when you can win without him? Should he just trust you'll choose to "share" the win. And lol, you believe that mate