AFL 1v1 Drafts

Discussion in 'Aussie Rules Football Discussion' started by Skippos, Jul 15, 2012.

Page 13 of 14

  1. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Jamie Elliot
    Jack Darling
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 24, 2014
    #241

  2. Skippos SM Morgan

    Luke Parker
    Adam Treloar
     
    Skippos, Jul 24, 2014
    #242

  3. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Jack Frost
    Brad Crouch
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #243

  4. Skippos SM Morgan

    Jaeger O'Meara
    Cam Guthrie
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #244

  5. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Luke Dahlhaus
    Devon Smith

    Lets get this over and done with tonight, I have to be on a plane at 6 and most likely wont be back on until 4, and that's with limited Internet.
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #245

  6. Skippos SM Morgan

    Dom Tyson
    Dylan Shiel
     
    Last edited: Jul 25, 2014
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #246

  7. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Brandon Ellis
    Anthony Miles
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #247

  8. Skippos SM Morgan

    Shaun Atley
    Brad Hill
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #248

  9. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Justin Clarke
    Reece Conca
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #249

  10. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    You stole my pick btw, ku,t.
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #250

  11. Skippos SM Morgan

    Tom Nicholls
    Troy Menzel
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #251

  12. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    B: A.Tomlinson, J.Frost, B.Ellis
    HB: B.Smith, J.Clarke, R.Conca
    C: J.Macrae, O.Wines, D.Prestia
    HF: H.Bennell, J.Darling, L.Dahlhaus
    F: D.Smith, J.Cameron, J.Elliott
    R: T.Hickey, L.Whitfield, B.Crouch
    I/C: A.Miles, -, -
    Sub: -

    Adam Tomlinson
    Tom Hickey
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #252

  13. Skippos SM Morgan

    Tom Mitchell
    Curtley Hampton
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #253

  14. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Stephen Coniglio
    Sam Mayes
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #254

  15. Skippos SM Morgan

    Jeremy McGovern
    Jack Hombsch

    Code:
    FB:	C. Guthrie	S. May		J. Hombsch
HB:	T. McKenzie	T. McDonald	S. Atley
C:	J. O'Meara	D. Heppell	A. Treloar
HF:	L. Parker	J. McGovern	T. Mitchell
FF:	C. Wingard	T. Lynch	T. Menzel
R:	T. Nicholls	D. Swallow	T. Liberatore
IC:	D. Tyson	D. Shiel	B. Hill		
SUB:	C. Hampton

    Much prefer my midfield and defense but your forwards are much better
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #255

  16. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Jack Viney

    B: A.Tomlinson, J.Frost, B.Ellis
    HB: B.Smith, J.Clarke, R.Conca
    C: J.Macrae, O.Wines, D.Prestia
    HF: H.Bennell, J.Darling, L.Dahlhaus
    F: D.Smith, J.Cameron, J.Elliott
    R: T.Hickey, L.Whitfield, B.Crouch
    I/C: A.Miles, J.Viney, S.Coniglio
    Sub: S.Mayes

    Prefer Nicholls to Hickey, and the midfields are on par. Reckon my defense and forwards are better, though.
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #256

  17. Skippos SM Morgan

    I wouldn't mind your defence if it wasn't 50% makeshift defenders.

    I'm not even sure how MacRae, Wines, Prestia, Whitfield, Crouch (Miles, Viney, Coniglio) is even close to O'Meara, Heppell, Treloar, Liberatore, Swallow (Tyson, Shiel, Hill)

    O'Meara > Whitfield
    Treloar > MacRae
    Swallow > Wines
    Heppell > Crouch
    Liberatore > Prestia
    Tyson > Miles
    Shiel > Coniglio
    Hill = Viney

    7.5 v 0.5 imo
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #257

  18. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Conca to play a similar role to Atley. Tomlinson 3rd kpd. Ellis probably the only one, but he's played back before.

    Prefer Wines to Swallow, Miles to Tyson, Viney to Hill and Prestia and Libba are on par. 3.5 to 4.5.
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #258

  19. Skippos SM Morgan

    Statistically Wines and Swallow are pretty similar. About as identical as two players could conceivably be, really. small gaps in different areas which cancel each other out mainly.

    But I don't know how after watching both one couldn't prefer Swallow. Just genuine class, inside and out. Wines doesn't have class, just strength.

    Miles v Tyson - Miles slightly statistically better but there's a reason GWS cbfd with him and it took him ages to get a look in at Richmond. He's a low impact accumulator. Tyson's a high impact inside/out mid. It's like saying Boak or Boyd. Boyd's numbers are better but Boak's clearly a better player

    The one I don't get is Prestia/Libba. Libba probably should have been AA last year and probably will be this year. Prestia's an outside leaning accumulator with very questionable disposal for someone who'd be considered 'elite' - Liberatore's efficiency is 5% better despite having a considerably higher spread of contested possessions than Prestia. He's quite possibly the best clearance player around. Prestia's just a good honest accumulator with not much of a hurt factor. That's the one I really don't get. There aren't many mids in the comp I'd take ahead of Liberatore. Prestia's well below him imo.

    Viney/Hill not going to argue it. One is unable to win his own ball the other is unable to use the ball. Both fundamentally flawed players so it's all about whether you prefer inside grunt or outside run.

    But I'd be very curious as to what others thought on Swallow/Wines, Miles/Tyson and Prestia/Libba

    Should make a thread in the polls board on BF Reframe, see what they think lol.
     
    Skippos, Jul 25, 2014
    #259

  20. Please_Reframe PP Reframe

    Prefer Wines to Swallow simply because how he can impact a game. When the ball is in the hands of Wines during crunch time, he performs extremely well. Swallow doesn't seem to be an extremely high impact player for mine. There's a reason Wines is the most-compared young player on the bf polls board, I'll add as well. :p

    Miles - Ill admit, I haven't seen a heap of him. Not sure whether this is due to him being a massive accumulator/low impact player or not, but he just seems to do everything right. Tyson still has a few flaws that I can't pinpoint. Of course Miles does too, but he just seems a tad more polished.

    Prestia isn't as good a player as Libba no doubt. Again, though, Prestia oozes x-factor and outside run. Not only does he have that something special about him, he just does everything right too. Knows where the goals are, hits targets, has very good outside run - love him. That makes them equal IMO.

    Would be interesting to see what bf thinks, actually. No doubt you'll copy and paste parts of that post though and convince people otherwise. :p
     
    Please_Reframe, Jul 25, 2014
    #260
Page 13 of 14

Share This Page