This Trade Game is simple, it's a bit of a competition to see who is the best Trade Maker. I will put up a Trade Scenario each week & you have to make a trade to solve the problem. I, with the help of some supporters of the respective teams will choose the best trade. You may also trade draft picks. Trade Scenario #1 Tavis Boak wants to go back home to Either Geelong or North Melbourne, you decide which club you would like to make the deal with or all of them. If you get picked as Geelong's best trade option: 10 Points North Melbourne: 5 Note: There will be a ladder of points.
Yeah not playing a game where a supporter chooses the winner. way too subjective. what defines a winning trade anyway? the most balanced one or something?
The most realistic pretty much. So if Boak was going to North or Geelong, make an deal you think would happen if they actually made a trade.
Anthony can't kick a ball and is exactly what port don't need, garlett can't get an afl game. why north though? understand geelong but there's no way in hell boak would ever go north Why would duncan move to port?
Anthony has improved and he gets a bit of the ball, port could do with his ball winning ability. Garlett has been unlucky, tearing VFL up all year, just cant crack an AFL spot with swallow, JZ, Cunners ahead of him in that role. He has said that North and Geelong are the clubs he would go to.
Anyway, I'll go with Geelong receives: Travis Boak Port Adelaide receives: George Horlin-Smith, first round compensation pick (Gary Ablett)
dont know why he would want to stay in Port, they are playing terrible and i cant see improvement for a while