Athlai picks Best and Worst Squad Picks CPL 4 (Complete)

Discussion in 'CPL Cricket' started by Athlai, Jan 15, 2020.

  1. Dan DB Wayne

    holy fuck morgie drafted Umesh Karunaratne. That's amazing.
     
  2. Athlai JJD Heads

    Genuinely think everyone has drafted really really well this time.
     
  3. Dan DB Wayne

  4. Athlai JJD Heads

    A D is a fail ffs
     
  5. Phlegm SP Phlegm

    lots of people like a d
     
  6. Phlegm SP Phlegm

    fair warning for bird offers, bring quality. contrary to athlais insistence i need to trade him, i don't actually need to trade him.

    i am quite happy to have the best injury cover in the competition. i don't need your reserve batsmen.

    the best offer by far was from howe and dan. i just find the player they offered tricky to rate (he's a good player) given he'd require the team having a reshuffle.
     
  7. Boobidy BJ Gemmell

    I'll give you Peirson.
     
  8. Athlai JJD Heads

    I remember watching the game where that guy appeared. It was sooooooooooo weird and glorious. It’s probably my favourite cricket memory.
     
  9. morgieb MC Burridge

    That gif is amazing. It would’ve been even better if you saw it live. Given how much of an awkward cunt I am it fits perfectly too haha.
     
  10. Gazza GJ Weaver

    Happy to take the only F this time round.
     
  11. Athlai JJD Heads

    I haven't gotten to Dev yet
     
  12. Athlai JJD Heads

    jimmy_c8
    Team name: Cricketers Arms
    Name Rating: D

    You can't have cricket in the name ffs.


    Squad:
    Rory Burns
    Kraigg Braithwaite
    Theunis de Bruyn
    Sam Hain
    Marcus Stoinis
    Dinesh Chandimal
    BJ Watling
    Sam Curran
    Jason Behrendorff
    Mohammad Abbas
    Taijul Islam

    Chris Rushworth
    Liam Dawson
    Tom Kohler-Cadmore
    Harry Podmore
    Mayank Markande
    Dan Lawrence
    Josh Inglis


    Squad Depth: B-

    I tried to do a write up on this squad 2 times before this one. There is just something about this team that I hate. It's hard for me to put the finger on how good or bad it is. It's just there. There are good picks and there are bad picks and this is a team that could probably jam it's way into the top 8 or bottom 8 with equal ease.

    Best Pick: Mohammad Abbas - Round 1
    Morgs on Abbas: Would've been a dream pick a year ago, but now I feel like his bubble has burst post-injury. Still, the post-injury sample size isn't huge so he should still be quality in this, though I do think there were a couple of better quicks left over.
    Cribb's Best Pick: Dinesh Chandimal - Round 3
    Morgs on Chandimal : Though he hasn't played much Tests lately, he still provides excellent balance to a side given he can bat 4/5 and keep. Very good pick.
    Worst Pick: Taijul Islam - Round 6
    Morgs on Taijul: Hmmm....he does have a Test record at least, but it's not a good one. I guess I can see the logic though, especially given the other spinners left over have even more concerns.


    This team has so many journeyman in the wider squad, probably the most of anyone, but it has some h4x in it too. I really hate it. It's decent enough but I'd say it's close to Spark in how much looking at this team makes me mad. Dunno why really, might need to see a professional but enough about me. I'm a big fan of Taijul btw, after Watling hes my second favourite player in the team, but he ain't round 6 material. Middle of the pack bound.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 23, 2020
  13. Athlai JJD Heads

    Captain
    Team name: The Dongs
    Name Rating: B

    I wish instead of the admittedly funny Dongs, you named them the Carnivorous Cannibals or something. Would be gun.

    Squad:
    1. Keegan Petersen
    2. Kaushal Silva +
    3. Hashim Amla
    4. Virat Kohli
    5. Roshen Silva
    6. Roston Chase (5)
    7. Mosaddek Hossain (6)
    8. Ben Coad (3)
    9. Umesh Yadav (1)
    10. Kyle Abbott (2)
    11. Jack Leach (4)

    12. Naseem Shah
    13. Liton Das +
    14. Aditya Sarwate
    15. James Hildreth
    16. Tendai Chatara
    17. Tim David
    18. Abhinav Mukund



    Squad Depth: A

    Twice you poached picks from me I'm sure would be mine. Das hurt the most though. Probably the most underrated drafter there is, Captain always selects a h4x XI and is one of the stronger in the back end of the draft and CPL 19/20 was no exception. Destined for the finals again.

    Best Pick: Liton Das - Round 13
    Morgs on Das: Hard to assess. His international performances haven't been flash but has dominated domestics. Weighted against that is that he's probably not the only Bangladeshi batsman to dominate domestics there and I question the quality of Bangaldeshi domestics. Still, probably a decent pick at this point especially given he's a keeper.
    Cribb's Best Pick: Jarrad Lysaught - Round 18
    Morgs on Lysaught : Morgie: Lysaught - I don’t know if he’s any good or not, but it doesn’t matter. What matters is the moment around this pick. For giving us one of the best CPL moments of all-time, this is an amazing pick.
    Worst Pick: Mosaddek Hossain - Round 11
    Dev on Hossain: Interesting one in that his recent FC form has actually been kinda bad even though his overall record remains great. Still, should probably be a good option in this.


    Mosaddek is fine. A team with no real bad picks and plenty of VERY strong picks for the round. Captain has a better team than me and I don't like it. Cribb wants to say that you shouldn't have traded Lysaught and that Lysaught is h4x, but Mukund is a ridiculous "r18" pickup.

    I can't wait to knock you out of the tournament undeservedly again. It'll be so much fun.
     
  14. Cribbage RG Cribb

    :lol: Brutal.

    The team is perfectly fine. Too many mediocre county players in the back half most of the early picks were great. I hope he beats you by an innings and 258 runs.
     
    morgieb, Captain and Chewie like this.
  15. DVMace09 Member

    Think you might've gotten me and captain a little mixed up here Athlai
     
  16. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Nah technically Captain picked Lysaught Round 18 and then traded him away, so I gave Lysaught as a bit of a troll answer for his best pick.

    He definitely shouldn't have traded him. It's the Larkin for Renshaw trade all over again. Captain is the new Morgie.
     
    Captain and Dan like this.
  17. DVMace09 Member

    Well in that case Athlai got me and Morgie mixed up instead because I definitely didn't comment on Mosaddek :p
     
  18. Captain SSD Dong

    <3 good to know I've improved from the days of picking Goodwin and making him open.

    Also who is the other player I poached from you? This gives me great pleasure.
     
  19. Cribbage RG Cribb

    This time you're going to pick Das and make him keep even though he's 50.031% sure he doesn't want to.
     
  20. Captain SSD Dong

    Nah he's feeling good about his keeping after taking the gloves for most of the BPL

    He also feels good about not going to the Avengers
     

Share This Page